Submitted by Greg Quinlan on Friday 31st October 2025
Published on Tuesday 30th December 2025
Current status: Open
Open until: Tuesday 30th June 2026
Current Signatures: 22
(count is updated approximately hourly)
Relevant Departments
Tagged with
Abolished ~ Bears ~ Compensation ~ Employers ~ employment rights ~ Failed ~ Fairness ~ Fairs ~ Law ~ Reduced ~ Reform ~ Restore ~ rights act ~ Standards ~ Unfair
Abolish "Polkey deductions" in compensation for unfair dismissal
The “Polkey deduction” lets tribunals reduce compensation for unfair dismissal by estimating the chance an employee would have been dismissed even if a fair process had been followed. We think this undermines the statutory right to a fair procedure and rewards employers who bypass due process.
We ask the Government to amend the Employment Rights Act 1996 so that, where dismissal is found procedurally unfair, compensation is not reduced on “it would have happened anyway” grounds. Employers should bear the consequences of failing to follow a fair process. We believe this reform would restore the protective purpose of unfair dismissal law, vastly improve workplace standards, and provide clear incentives for lawful, respectful and fair dismissals.
If you want to sign this petition (as opposed to merely discuss it), you need to do that on the government's e-Petitions website.
216.73.217.179 Tue, 23 Jun 2026 13:53:42 +0100